Buffalo Nickels (also referred to as Indian Nickels), were minted from 1913 to 1938. Matte Proofs were made for collectors from 1913 to 1916. The 1937-D 3-legged Buffalo Nickel, created as a result of excessive die polishing of Black Diamond's right foreleg, is one of the most popular varieties in the series.

GreatCollections has sold 17,310 Buffalo Nickels in the past 11 years, selling at prices from $6 to $104,063, in grades 1 to 68+. Of these, 2474 were approved by CAC.

The design was made by: James Earle Fraser.


Please select an item from this series of Buffalo Nickels:


Filter
Sort by
 

Grader
   
Grade
 
Sold Buffalo Nickels
Upcoming Buffalo Nickels
Grade / Item
Sold Price
Photo
Date
Grade / Item
Current Price
Photo
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 6 bids
May 2020
$12,750
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 39 bids
Dec 2018
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 44 bids
Feb 2021
$625
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 18 bids
Feb 2021
$2,600
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 30 bids
Feb 2021
$13,500
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 41 bids
Feb 2021
$9,600
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 46 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 28 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 20 bids
Feb 2021
$3
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 17 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 42 bids
Feb 2021
$2
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 28 bids
Feb 2021
$525
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 15 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 30 bids
Jan 2021
$466
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 23 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 18 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 20 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 14 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 15 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 10 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 19 bids
Feb 2021
$20
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 32 bids
Feb 2021
$11
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 11 bids
Feb 2021
$2
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 5 bids
Feb 2021
$24
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 12 bids
Feb 2021
$2
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 26 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 14 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 23 bids
Feb 2021
$77
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 16 bids
Feb 2021
$2
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 14 bids
Feb 2021
$2
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 8 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 12 bids
Feb 2021
$130
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 1 bids
Feb 2021
$2,650
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 12 bids
Feb 2021
$26,000
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 37 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 19 bids
Dec 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 22 bids
Dec 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 21 bids
Nov 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 11 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 16 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 14 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 12 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 3 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 1 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 25 bids
Jan 2021
$480
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 10 bids
Jan 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 4 bids
Jan 2021
$12,845
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 19 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 22 bids
Oct 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 26 bids
May 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 9 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 8 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 10 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 25 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 8 bids
Feb 2021
$130
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 17 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 4 bids
Sep 2019
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 8 bids
Feb 2021
$40
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 37 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 1 bids
Feb 2021
$160
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 23 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 12 bids
Feb 2021
$60
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 12 bids
Feb 2021
$412
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 6 bids
Feb 2021
$3
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 4 bids
Feb 2021
$75
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 6 bids
Feb 2021
$1,686
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 6 bids
Feb 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 7 bids
Feb 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 25 bids
Feb 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 11 bids
Feb 2021
$1,000
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 20 bids
Feb 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 7 bids
Sep 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 17 bids
Aug 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 12 bids
Aug 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 18 bids
Jun 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 17 bids
Nov 2020
$325
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 15 bids
Jun 2020
$300
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 7 bids
May 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 13 bids
Jan 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 8 bids
Sep 2019
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 4 bids
Mar 2019
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 6 bids
Nov 2020
$56
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 24 bids
Sep 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 28 bids
May 2019
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 17 bids
Nov 2015
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 11 bids
Feb 2021
$105
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 1 bids
Feb 2021
$2
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 11 bids
Feb 2021
$11
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 7 bids
Feb 2021
$1,000
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 10 bids
Feb 2021
$200
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 7 bids
Feb 2021
$440
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 7 bids
Feb 2021
$650
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 1 bids
Feb 2021
$325
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 32 bids
Feb 2021
$1,040
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 5 bids
Feb 2021
$225
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 10 bids
Feb 2021
$775
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 19 bids
Feb 2021
$16
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 8 bids
Feb 2021
$520
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 18 bids
Feb 2021
$185
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 18 bids
Feb 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 16 bids
Feb 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 27 bids
Feb 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 5 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 1 bids
Feb 2021
$500
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 18 bids
Jan 2021
$87
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 8 bids
Jan 2021
$175
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 6 bids
Jan 2021
$192
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 9 bids
Jan 2021
$1,625
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 16 bids
Jan 2021
$450
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 18 bids
Feb 2021
$400
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 2 bids
Feb 2021
$600
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 6 bids
Jan 2021
$1,950
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 12 bids
Jan 2021
$20
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 10 bids
Jan 2021
$455
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 6 bids
Jan 2021
$46
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 19 bids
Feb 2021
$350
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 15 bids
Feb 2021
$75
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 26 bids
Feb 2021
$2
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 1 bids
Feb 2021
$35
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 1 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 6 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 12 bids
Jan 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 22 bids
Jan 2021
$69
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 12 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 19 bids
Dec 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 18 bids
Dec 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 18 bids
Dec 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 10 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 8 bids
Feb 2021
$205
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 2 bids
Jan 2021
$195
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 4 bids
Jan 2021
$40
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 21 bids
Jan 2021
$146
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 15 bids
Jan 2021
$68
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 10 bids
Feb 2021
$170
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 4 bids
Jan 2021
$51
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 9 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 17 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 24 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 18 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 22 bids
Feb 2021
$5
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 10 bids
Feb 2021
$300
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 20 bids
Feb 2021
$135
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 26 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 19 bids
Jan 2021
$125
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 18 bids
Jan 2021
$60
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 21 bids
Feb 2021
$34
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 11 bids
Jan 2021
$15
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 21 bids
Jan 2021
$4
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 20 bids
Jan 2021
$19
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 20 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 13 bids
Nov 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 11 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 16 bids
Feb 2021
$25
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 10 bids
Feb 2021
$11
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 14 bids
Feb 2021
$48
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 20 bids
Jan 2021
$30
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 7 bids
Jan 2021
$48
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 8 bids
Feb 2021
$48
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 9 bids
Feb 2021
$32
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 14 bids
Jan 2021
$16
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 20 bids
Jan 2021
$18
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 17 bids
Jan 2021
$26
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 8 bids
Nov 2020
$18
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 22 bids
Feb 2021
$2
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 13 bids
Jan 2021
$4
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 1 bids
Jan 2021
$2
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 16 bids
Jan 2021
$46
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 13 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 8 bids
Nov 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 1 bids
Feb 2021
$1
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 4 bids
Feb 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 10 bids
Feb 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 14 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 12 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 8 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 7 bids
Feb 2021
$2
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 11 bids
Feb 2021
$48
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 1 bids
Jan 2021
$13
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 31 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 10 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 2 bids
Dec 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 4 bids
Feb 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 24 bids
Jan 2021
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 5 bids
Aug 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 1 bids
Jul 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 2 bids
May 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 10 bids
May 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 2 bids
Jan 2020
Login or Join
(Free & Quick)
 2 bids
Nov 2015